![]() Once I had decided to write a novel about my grandfather, I knew that I wanted to hew to the facts of his life as closely as possible. That, of course, required extensive research—research into the public records that revealed his movements and actions, research into the other people who inhabited his world, research into the cities where he made his home, and research into the history and culture of the United States between 1900 and 1942. For me, one of the most difficult aspects of writing Next Train Out was knowing when it was time to stop researching and start writing. In the end, external circumstances pushed me to abandon my feeble efforts to educate myself and find the courage to put words on a page. I had enrolled in the Author Academy at the Carnegie Center for Literacy and Learning in Lexington, Ky., and my mentor wanted to see a fledgling manuscript. Although there was still research I wanted to pursue, I stopped making that my emphasis and turned my attention to creating a fictional world. Occasionally, of course, I still had to stop writing and look up some historic detail or spend a little time pursuing a lead that had just turned up. Sometimes the leads that most intrigued me were unfortunately set aside as new distractions demanded my attention. Earlier this summer I finally picked up the phone to pursue one of those leads. I had some notes that indicated that, in 2000, Effie Mae’s great-granddaughter had lived one county north of my home. I didn’t know if that was still the case, or whether the contact information I had for her was still valid. But since I finally had some time, I was determined to see if I could find her. Eventually, one of the phone numbers I tried rang through. “Hi. My name is Sallie Showalter. Is this Storme Vanover?” I asked tentatively. “Yes.” “Ms. Vanover, I live nearby in Scott County, and I recently wrote a novel about the woman I believe was your great-grandmother—Effie Mae Frady.” “Yes, that’s right. Effie Mae was my grandmother Edna’s mother.” “Well, my grandfather was married to your great-grandmother and, if you’re interested, I’d love to meet you and give you a copy of the book.” With that prompt, Storme, who was driving her car at the time, began to share some of her family’s story. Last week I met with her for an hour in her home in northwestern Grant County, and she graciously filled in more of the details. Storme is indeed the granddaughter of Effie Mae’s younger daughter Edna (whom I call Eileen in the book). I knew from my research (or rather, from Chuck’s research) that Edna had eventually moved to Michigan and married there. Storme was born in Detroit. What I did not know was what happened after Effie Mae left her three older children in Kentucky, including Edna, when she and her youngest son Doug moved to Cincinnati. The 1920 census confirms that Effie and all her children were living with Effie’s brother in the Logmont coal camp. But I had to imagine what happened to the three older children Effie Mae left behind. In my naiveté—which reflects the ease of my own life—I decided that the children stuck together and successfully navigated their way to adulthood. As I look back on it now, I created a rosy moving picture story, complete with a softening scrim that subdued the hardships they must have endured. In reality, as Storme shared with me, Edna, at some point after her seventh birthday, was put on an orphan train and landed in a Catholic orphanage. No one knows where that orphanage was, but I was distressed to read the stories of neglect and abuse at a number of those institutions in Kentucky and elsewhere. According to Storme, Edna eventually initiated steps to take her vows as a nun. But her plans were derailed when she became pregnant by a young priest-in-training—or was it a truck driver? Edna's story would vary. Wherever the truth lay, it seems that Edna’s older sister Vivian (I call her Valarie in the book) cared for baby Shirley for some time, perhaps contrary to Edna's wishes. Edna eventually moved to Michigan, and Edna and Shirley were reunited when Shirley was six. The father of the child had no further role in their lives, and Edna and Vivian never spoke again. This is just a glimpse into a family story full of tragedy and mésalliances as well as love and loyalty. That story is Storme’s story, and I will leave it to her to tell. But I’ve thought about what I’ve learned from her about the fate of Effie Mae’s children. If I had reached out to Storme while I was writing the book, would I have portrayed Effie’s story any differently? Did Effie Mae know what happened to Edna? To Vivian and Lynn, her older son? Did Effie herself put Edna on that train? Or was that Edna’s father, whom Edna was devoted to? Or was it her uncle, who had taken the whole family in? I didn’t pursue a lead while I was writing my grandfather’s story, and I now know more of the truth underlying his tale. That truth doesn’t change the work of fiction I created. But it does deepen my understanding of the lives interwoven with his own, and it reveals the hidden complexities of all our stories.
4 Comments
Joseph Anthony
9/13/2020 02:16:55 pm
Wordsworth says we "half create and what perceive." You would have had to half-create even if you had had this part of the story. Your story might have been grimmer, but it still wouldn't haven't been more true. And as true. Your imagination would have just gone in that direction. My last novel checked me repeatedly with real history, but I found myself steering around facts like a canoe steers around boulders in a stream. The facts helped in many ways. Anyway, great blog. Joe
Reply
HANNAH HELM
9/13/2020 02:35:40 pm
I haven't had a chance to order and read the book yet, but I've been somewhat keeping up through Rick. What an incredible story you've uncovered and what an adventure of sorts. Your Covid time has been far from boring!
Reply
Barbara Fallis
9/13/2020 07:28:06 pm
Oddly what crossed my mind was the scene in the book when Effie Mae found the paper about Lyons' child and former wife. She was horrified and asked herself and Doug how Lyons could have left his child behind. Yet Effie Mae did that same thing. And I recall years ago reading a book that I think was The Orphan Train. Fiction and non fiction aren't always that far apart.
Reply
Bob Patrick
9/13/2020 08:13:42 pm
What a fascinating story. I wonder why Vivian and Edna never spoke again? Your efforts to track down the details of your family are extraordinary and have sure led to some interesting discoveries. And to be able to meet some of the people who connect with your novel must be quite rewarding.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Details
Archives
November 2022
Categories
All
|